Uploads finally working, Design for desktops upload

Finally the uploads appaer to work at home again; now, below is a picture of my 4 designs and descriptions for a desktop. I will go into detail into each after the image but bear in mind each image must:
-Have the shipley college logo
-have plenty of room for around 22 desktop icons
-contain the works "media suite"
-contain the "rules" we think in college are the most important somewhere written on the desktop

***NOTE: i realise the quality is not great so i will give a full description of what each design is and says below, also the inspirational images for my design were printed on both sides of 2 pieces of A4, i will try to upload at some point in the future***

Idea 1 (top left):
"The idea was a dark background, with a smokey/whispy effect in front of it. coming down the middle a very bright/light sword (to contrast with the darker background) it will also attract the viewers attention, a camera will be atop the sword and the words "media suite" will be written on the hilt; the shipley college logo will be on the camera. There is plenty of space for icons, and the rules/points will be written along the whisps of smoke

Idea 2 (top right):
"The idea is a hand holding up the shiply college logo (which is "melting" through the fingers like sand) "media suite" is wrriten on the arm holding the logo, it will have a light background (bringing the viewers attention to the logo and icons) leaving plenty of room for icons and rules."

Idea 3 (bottom left):
Large drawing of the college ominously looming next to the character walking past, with the college logo near the top of the desktop (looking almost like a film title) there wont be as much room for rules or icons than the other ideas however the visual aspect may appear more impressive and be harder to achieve.

Idea 4 (bottom right)
This idea is very mystic and spacey, (combined a variety of inspirational desktops i found) it would have a very dark/space blue background, littered with stars, with a large looming "planet" filling most of the background, with lighting shining through behind it, and the words "media suite" being on the top of it and the rules coming down it. there will also be a constalation of stars that look like some kind of warrior/guardian/protector whose shield bears the logo of shipley college. i really like this idea, and it may actually be easier than the other three, depends on the "star guardian"


So those are my suggestions, any feedback would be appreciated or if anyone has a favourite and why :)

***NOTE, i will only be comparing my finished final design with proffesional work, otherwise i won't really know what to compare each individual image too.***